Allisonville Home & Garden by Sullivan - Fishers IN

Fairly unassuming from the outside but Holy Cow Batman, this place is fantastic! almost like stepping into another world. An absolutely amazing selection of plants, flowers, gifts, Knick Knacks, pots, grills, and items for your patio/outdoor space. And a bistro! You could easily spend the entire afternoon (or longer) browsing. We liked it so much we visited two weeks in a row.

I’ve been shopping at this nursery regularly since spring and have probably spent several hundred dollars here over the past few months. Most of the employees have always been very kind and helpful, which is why today’s experience stood out so much to me. While waiting in line this morning, I was asked by the manager to move and stand separately to the side, even though there was no one else there and the customers behind me continued waiting in the original line without being asked to move. It immediately felt uncomfortable and unnecessary. Later, I found a beautiful snake plant that had clearly been sitting dry for quite some time, with visible dehydration wrinkles on the leaves. I politely asked whether there might be any discount due to the condition. The employee helping me was very kind and even offered to ask the manager. When the manager came over, he stared at me, repeatedly rubbed his hand roughly across the snake plant leaves, and asked, “Where is the damage?” I pointed out the visible dehydration wrinkling on the leaves. He then picked up the plant and said, “There’s no discount. You can not buy it,” before walking away. I completely understand stores having pricing policies, and I would have respected a simple “no.” What disappointed me was the unnecessarily rude and dismissive attitude throughout the interaction. I still purchased the plant because I genuinely loved it, but the experience left me feeling uncomfortable and unwelcome. ————————————————————- ******Update on 5/20/26****** Thank you to Jenny for reaching out and taking this seriously. It made me feel that customer concerns truly matter here, and this kind of behavior will not become part of the culture. I will continue supporting this nursery, it’s a special local garden shop for our community.

Held our company Grand Opening event in January and it was GREAT! The staff helped us coordinate all of the details and were very flexible with custom signage and decor. Would recommend for your next event.

Edit: Thank you for the quick response! Perhaps I was just confused, however, the third sentence in your response still reflects the last sentence in my original review. Best, ———————— We used to love coming here when it was a plant shop. Today unfortunately I noticed that they had turned a section of the Tropical House Plants area into another dining area. Felt as though I had to navigate around people looking at lunch menus just to see a philodendron. This is no longer a plant shop, this is the mess hall at the mall now. It’s become an ever changing labyrinth of Slider Stations, BBQ land, and people waiting to be seated. I just want to get plants like I always have. Now you can’t even walk through the building without getting caught up in the church lunch crowd. The first couple cafes were cute and fun. Now I’m just expecting a cafeteria where the greenhouse is on my next trip back. You guys forgot about your original customers. Now you just cater to large families wanting cheese burgers.

If you love plants this is the place for you. I really enjoyed my visit to Allisonville home and garden. They had such a fun variety of house and garden plants. The prices were very fair and the plants were healthy. I also enjoyed the home decor and boutique they had inside too. Overall I think this is one of the best plant shops in the area. I highly recommend stopping by and checking this place out!